Showing posts with label economics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label economics. Show all posts

11/24/13

Blaming the Victims: Media Bias Against Struggling Millennials (Truthout)

Originally published by Truthout. 

Michael Corcoran
November 20, 2013

It has become a common refrain in the mainstream media: The economic problems that young people face are the product of generational laziness and a sense of entitlement. People between the ages of 16 and 24 have an unemployment rate of 16.3 percent, more than twice the national average, and an alarming 36 percent of adults age 18-31 are living with their parents.
"Word that six million young people are not working or studying comes as no surprise to anyone with a millennial in the basement," writes Jennifer Graham in an op-ed titled "A Generation of Idle Trophy Kids," for the Boston Globe. Millennials' describes, loosely, the generation born between 1980 and 2000. "It's young people who don't leave the house at all, not because they're scared like agoraphobics, but because their needs are met and they're content."
To say that Graham's article is a woeful oversimplification would be to give it way too much credit. The article is an embarrassing debacle, filled with worthless platitudes to support an argument that is insulting not only to young and poor people but to anyone who values critical-thinking skills. Graham fails to provide any serious examination of the economic conditions facing young people, and the article lacks any significant data to back up her claim that millennials are a "minimally employable crop" of slackers who lack "the motivation to provide for themselves."
She also seems to make the racist and classist assumption that all young people are white, privileged members of the middle class who have the luxury of returning to suburban homes (as opposed to, say, park benches or homeless shelters) when they lack steady employment. Conveniently, she ignores things like the fact that 57 percent of young black adults are either "near" or in "deep poverty."
It is tempting to ignore such a weak and unsubstantiated argument, but this will not do, given that the Globe's article is rather consistent with a widespread, systemic media bias against not only young people but poor and working-class people in general. The implication is unambiguous: Poor people, of all ages, are that way because they are lazy, entitled or amoral - never mind the actual economic conditions they face.
In fact, as if they were intentionally attempting to demonstrate the narrow parameters of debate that exist in mainstream media circles, even an article by a Globe editorial board member (who is a millennial) that aims to refute Graham's op-ed, manages to repeat some of its most galling weaknesses, including a notable lack of evidence to back up its claims. The rebuttal, like the original op-ed, turns what should be a serious issue - poverty among young adults - and reduces it to a few witty jokes ("we'll take responsibility for Miley Cyrus") and hipster phrases (the article concludes as such: "(drops mic) I'm out"). The article also falls into the familiar trap of assuming that all young people are privileged whites whose main priority is not finding food and shelter but having "the nice things we grew up with." This presumes of course, that all young people grew up with "suburban homes," computers, digital cable and other elements of the four-car-garage lifestyle the author describes. It might interest the Globe editorial board to know that most young people in today's world did not grow up in such decadence, and many barely scraped by and have no family support. This collection of Globearticles is basically a back-and-forth between white people discussing decidedly first-world problems.
The Globe's worthless offerings on the subject notwithstanding, there can be no doubt that the issue of the economic plight of young people is worth examining. But to do so requires a serious look at the real economic conditions young adults face and the reasons these conditions exist. Graham's article, and many others like it, generally fail to consider the context in which young people are struggling to find decent jobs, including thelong-term economic impacts of deregulation and neoliberalism pushed by state managers and wealthy elites for some three decades now, which have kept wages stagnant for people of all ages, including young people; theimpact of the 2008 economic crisis (mostly caused by people born well before 1980); the college affordability crisis; and the fact that low-wage service-sector jobs tend to be where job growth is.

Read the rest here. 

11/20/11

Michael Corcoran on Ring of Fire Radio discussing 'Democrats and the Death of Keynesian Economics'


Note: I am having some trouble with the embed feature on YouTube. To watch it please click on the above link, or you watch it on the Ring of Fire website, here.

10/30/11

Michael Corcoran Discusses the Death of Keynesian Economics With Rick Smith


Michael Corcoran Discusses the Death of Keynesian Economics with Rick Smith

by: Rick Smith, The Rick Smith Show | Radio Interview

Press play to listen to Michael Corcoran's interview with Rick Smith about his latest story, "Democrats and the Death of Keynesian Economics":

Click here, to listen to more interview with Truthout authors on The Rick Smith Show.

10/18/11

Democrats and the Death of Keynesian Economics

Originally published at Truthout. '

It is quite remarkable, given the nature of the recent debate overeconomic policy in Washington, that a Wikipedia articles exists today called, "2008-2009 Keynesian resurgence." Today, both political parties have had an obsession with "austerity measures" for at least last year or so - which includes putting Medicare andSocial Security on the chopping block. Barack Obama's weak job bill, which was dead on arrival, only further demonstrates how twisted priorities are in Washington. So, it is actually hard to believe that, in the aftermath of the near-collapse of the economy in 2008, Maynard Keynes, who advocated government intervention in the economy to increase demand during downturns, was making a comeback.

But for a brief moment in time, this was indeed the case. After the 2008 bailout of Bear Stearns, Martin Wolf, an economics writer for the Financial Times and normally a staunch supporter of free-market globalization, wrote: "Remember March 14 2008: it was the day the dream of global free market capitalism died." In the same article, he quoted Joseph Ackerman, the chief executive of Deutsche Bank, saying: "I no longer believe in the market's self-healing power." In an October 10 article, The Washington Post - in all seriousness - suggested that the current economic crises meant the "The End Of American Capitalism" as we know it. The cover of Time magazine in February 2009, said, "We are all Socialists Now," referencing the need for government intervention to save us from the ills of capitalism. "Whether we want to admit it or not," the article observed, "the America of 2009 is moving toward a modern European state."

As frightening and tragic as the economic crisis of 2008 was, having these widely held doctrinal assumptions about the power of the so-called "free market" spun on their head did provide some hope. Maybe there could be some sort of shift toward a more humane mixed economy that reined in the horrific excesses of contemporary capitalism. The country was optimistic; a new president had just been elected and his chief of staff Rahm Emanuel, famously said that he "never wanted a serious crisis to go to waste." The Nation magazine even called for a "New New Deal."

What followed, unfortunately, was a very underwhelming flirtation with Keynesian policies (such as the too-small stimulus bill in 2009), which was then swiftly overwhelmed with bipartisan discussions about how to gut government spending and create on austerity movement. This occurred despite the fact that the need for Keynesian economic policies are just as great now, in the face of crippling unemployment, as they were in 2008-09.

Read the rest here.

10/7/10

Media Continue Bank Bailout Advocacy

Originally published at Extra!, the magazine for Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting.

Michael Corcoran and Stephen Maher

For corporate media, the verdict is already in: The Troubled Assets Relief Program (TARP), the unpopular program that redistributed some $700 billion of U.S. taxpayer funds upwards, to the very financial institutions that contributed to the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression, is an unabashed success.

It is hardly stunning that corporate media would react favorably to one of the biggest boons for big corporations in U.S. history. When the bailout initially failed to make it through Congress in 2008 due to House opposition, journalists quickly accepted and reinforced the narrative that the unpopular legislation--which gave unprecedented power to the Treasury Department with virtually no mechanism for oversight or review--needed to be passed so urgently that a serious national debate was not even possible (Extra!, 1/09).

"In the Congress of the United States, the insane are now running the asylum," wrote Dana Milbank in the Washington Post (9/30/08). The Post editorial page produced three editorials in three days (9/30/08=10/2/08) in support of the policy. New York Times columnist Thomas Friedman (10/1/08) claimed, "We have House members, many of whom I suspect can't balance their own checkbooks, rejecting a complex rescue package because some voters, whom I fear also don't understand, swamped them with phone calls."

As Dean Baker and Kris Warner of the Center for Economic and Policy Research noted (Extra!, 1/09), despite claims echoed throughout the media that the bill was too urgent to even be subject to reasonable scrutiny, the Treasury Department "took no action for 10 days after the bill had been passed."



Now that the program is coming to an end, media--with a few notable exceptions like Gretchen Morgenson at the New York Times (4/18/10)--are claiming the corporate bailout they so fervently supported has been a monumental success. Two primary claims have been pervasive: that TARP was a good idea that’s “working,” and that it was a “great deal for taxpayers” (Washington Post, 4/1/10). Progressive critiques challenging the official narrative have been almost entirely ignored by the corporate press, despite the fact that such challenges have appeared throughout alternative media (Pew Research Center, 4/28/10; FireDogLake, 7/15/10).

In the words of the Post editorial board (7/5/10), even though "pretty much everyone hated" the "$700 billion bailout fund," it has "arguably saved the U.S. economy.... Any member of Congress who supported TARP, Republican or Democrat, took a sensible risk that has been vindicated by the program's result."

Similarly, Reuters (8/19/10) reported that TARP's success would "dilute the previously potent political attack that lawmakers who voted for the bailout were rewarding Wall Street greed while putting taxpayers at risk." Former George W. Bush administration official James K. Glassman declared in a Wall Street Journal op-ed (8/26/10), "It has to be said that the TARP and the other financial rescues were necessary and efficient."



Prominent progressive critics contend TARP is a program that is doomed to failure. Even if it succeeds in temporarily rescuing the financial sector, the failure to enact broad systemic changes only increases the risk of future, more expensive bailouts. Dean Baker, for instance, suggested (CEPR, 7/5/10) that the "financial Armageddon" averted by TARP

>>>would have meant the demise of Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley and most of the other Wall Street titans, but probably would not have led to a qualitatively worse economic situation for the rest of us than what we actually saw. In fact, there would have been a great benefit from this financial Armageddon in that it would let the market wipe out the fast-dealing, high-flying Wall Street gang in a single blow.

This would eliminate the culture of synthetic CDOs and naked credit default swaps that provide ever more sophisticated and expensive ways to gamble. It would also eliminate many of the huge multi-million dollar paychecks that the Wall Street boys take home every year (or week). In other words, this is not obviously a bad story.<<<

Financial blogger Yves Smith (Naked Capitalism, 6/23/10) likewise criticized the Obama administration’s choice to “patch the system up with duct tape and baling wire, and if it looks even remotely operational, tout it as tremendous success,” rather than enacting serious reform. The choice, she continued, reflects the administration’s "decision to reconstitute, as much as possible, the banking industry that had just driven itself and the global economy off the cliff” and “to cast its lot with an unreformed banking industry."

Yet these important ideas were rarely presented to the American people by the corporate-owned press, thus limiting their impact and damaging citizens’ ability to come to informed conclusions. "I have almost never had my criticisms of the TARP in the media," said Baker in an e-mail to Extra!.

Indeed, media adhered to their time-honored practice of framing the debate between centrist Democrats and far-right conservatives (Extra!, 9=10/04)--in this case, restricting the “debate” to pro-TARP voices on one side and militant free-market absolutists on the other, who oppose the program as a violation of laissez-faire principles. That was the form the debate took on Fox Business Channel (12/22/09), TARP supporter Lawrence Ausubel, economics professor at University of Maryland, faced off against Cody Willard, a right-wing libertarian critic.

A New York Times article (7/1/10) looking back on TARP included critiques of the plan from conservatives like Sen. Richard Shelby (“blatant accounting fraud”) and Rep. Spencer Bachus (“a ridiculous scheme”), but ignored progressive critics in Congress, such as Rep. Dennis Kucinich and Sen. Bernie Sanders.



The claim that the taxpayers are being fully reimbursed by beneficiaries of TARP is likewise being vigorously advanced by the corporate press. The New York Times has been ebullient regarding the program's outcome for some time now (8/30/09): "Nearly a year after the federal rescue of the nation’s biggest banks, taxpayers have begun seeing profits from the hundreds of billions of dollars in aid.... So far, that experiment [TARP] is more than paying off."

More recently, the Times' Andrew Ross Sorkin asked (4/12/10), "What if, after all that panting over Washington’s bailout of the financial system, we learned that it actually worked?" He continued:

>>>Some officials [are] suggesting that if the economic recovery continues apace, the bailout program could eventually turn from red to black. That may seem far-fetched to anyone who remembers the dire predictions about banks like Citigroup, but the numbers tell a different story. The government’s $45 billion investment in Citigroup alone is on track to make a profit of nearly $11 billion, plus $8 billion or so in interest and other fees. People inside the administration no longer refer to Citigroup as the "Death Star"; now it is a "profit center.”<<<

Dean Baker (Beat the Press, 7/5/10) wondered whether the assertion that TARP did not cost the taxpayers anything is “based on ungodly stupidity or is just plain dishonest”:

>>>The TARP money was a form of insurance. The vast majority of insurance policies are never paid off, but that does not mean they have no value. The point here is that the banks were on the edge of going bankrupt. The government, through the TARP and the Fed, gave the banks the loans and the guarantees that assured the markets that the banks would survive.... This is all a gift from the taxpayers to some of the richest people in the country.<<<

In a rare instance where a progressive critic was quoted by the mainstream press on the issue--albeit buried in an otherwise upbeat TARP story by Sorkin (New York Times, 4/13/10)--Nobel laureate in economics Joseph Stiglitz said widespread efforts to glorify TARP's success are "disingenuous and a real attempt to distract people," as they don't factor in lost interest on the money spent. "Did we get back anything commensurate with the risk?... Clearly the answer is no," he said. Sorkin dismissively reminded readers that Stiglitz "has made a career of seeing every glass as half-empty."

Even Elizabeth Warren, who has been featured in the news as a potential leader for the new Consumer Financial Protection Agency, has been largely ignored by the press when she reported on TARP’s flaws. As the chair of the Congressional Oversight Panel monitoring the use of TARP funds, she issued a strong critique of TARP's impact on small banks in the panel's July report (Congressional Oversight Panel, 7/14/10), saying TARP "served Wall Street much better than anyone else." Neither the Post nor the Times published a single article citing Warren's findings. The panel’s May report (Congressional Oversight Panel, 5/12/10), also quite critical of aspects of TARP, was mostly ignored as well, getting only two small mentions in the Post (5/19/10, 8/4/10).

When TARP was pushed through with no sizable programs attached to help the average American (Economic Policy Institute, 9/29/08), the priority for policy makers became clear. As Baker observed in CounterPunch (6/2/10), the same people who praise TARP are now saying we must “act aggressively now to reduce the budget deficit” and “accept large cuts in Social Security and other important programs.”

"Why on earth," Baker asks, "should anyone trust what the bankers' economist accomplices are telling us?"

7/30/10

New Bankruptcy Legislation Could Provide Relief For Those Buried in Student Debt

Originally published in Campus Progress

New Bankruptcy Legislation Could Provide Relief For Those Buried in Student Debt

Legislation that would allow private student loans to be discharged in bankruptcy, could provide distressed borrowers with a fresh start and bring a major victory to those dedicated to student loan justice.

By Michael Corcoran
July 30, 2010

Valisha Cooks graduated from the University of Phoenix with loan payments that amounted to $1,150 a month, much of it in private loans. Her debt burden amounted to more than half of her take-home pay. “When I took out private student loans, I had no idea that I was condemning myself to a lifetime of ruined credit, harassment by collection agencies, and the hopelessness of endless debt,” she says at a recent hearing before Congress [PDF].

Cooks is one of an approximate 17 million who have private student loan, many of whom are trapped in mounds of student debt with little hope of repayment. The default rate for private student loans is officially 7.3 percent, although the reality is actually grimmer, since these numbers do not account for people who are in deferment or forbearance and are likely to default in the future. Normally, people who suffer under such massive debt can declare bankruptcy and discharge much of their debt burden, but in 2005 Congress passed bankruptcy legislation eliminating a student loan borrower’s option of last resort, discharging student loan debt in bankruptcy.

“Now, even though I have a good job, I can’t afford to pay all my bills in any one month, I go to food banks to feed my son, and I will never be able to afford a house,” she says. “I live in constant fear that the hammer will one day drop and ruin my life and the hope for my son’s future. It is a scary, hopeless feeling.”

It is to President Barack Obama’s credit that he has made student loan justice a priority so far in his presidency. The reforms he made as part of the reconciliation bill that passed healthcare reform in March—an expanded direct lending program, more relaxed methods of repayment, and increased Pell Grants—are some of most significant changes to help students fund higher education in decades.

But the new reforms, some of which do not go into effect until 2014, do not impact any of the millions of people who have already borrowed private loans to go to college. This leaves generations of former students struggling to keep their head above water as they deal with massive student loan debt in an era where college tuition has dramatically outpaced the rate of inflation for nearly 20 years and unemployment, especially for recent college grads, is at frightening levels. The Chronicle of Higher Education recently reported that 20 percent of student loans taken out since 1995 are in default (and some argue the number is higher). Private loans in particular, which are much less flexible than federal loans with repayment schedules and deferments, are often a major reason for the high default numbers. This is why both houses of Congress have introduced legislation that would once again allow private student loans to be discharged in bankruptcy (S. 3219 and H.R. 5043).

Read the rest here.

12/31/07

China: the next superpower?

The Independent asks the question: is 2008 the year a new superpower is born?

4/15/07

Rising inequality


Click here for more on rising economic inequality.

3/29/07

The shift continues.

The Plank's Jonathan Cohn (easily TNR's most interesting contributer) has the latest on another free trader, who has seen the flaws in the doctrine of neoloberalism.

The piece he cites, from today's Financial Times, is especially timely given yesterday's article in The Wall Street Journal about Alan S. Binder.

From the FT piece:

Which is the greatest threat to globalisation: the protesters on the streets every time the International Monetary Fund or the World Trade Organisation meets, or globalisation's cheerleaders, who push for continued market opening while denying that the troubles surrounding globalisation are rooted in the policies they advocate? A good case can be made that the latter camp presents the greater menace. ...

Rubinomics & The Democrats

Robert Kuttner in this month's American Prospect has a look into Robert Rubin's powerful influence over the Democratic Party, which still hold true today, in light of shifting attitudes on economics.

An interesting snippet:

And although he no longer raises large sums for political candidates himself, Rubin remains very close to others in the Wall Street Democratic money machine, and to its party conduits, particularly Senator Chuck Schumer, who heads the Democratic Senate Campaign Committee, and Representative Rahm Emanuel, Schumer's House counterpart in the 2006 campaign.

When the Democrats took back the House in 2006, incoming Speaker Nancy Pelosi advised the new Democratic caucus that its first two briefings would include one on defense, with three experts of differing views. On the economy, Robert Rubin would be appearing, solo.


It will be interesting to see how influential Rubin wil be on the Presidential candidates. To date Edwards's appears to be the only serious candidate who is advocating for an economic world view notably different from Rubin's. Clinton, unsurpisingly, is running the most conservative campaign on economic issues.

Rubin's position as the Democrats' economic seer is unfortunate in several related respects. First, the vision Rubin is selling offers nothing for an economically stressed electorate. His theory is that budget balance, free capital markets, and low interest rates are both necessary and mostly sufficient for broad prosperity. We might like new social spending, but alas, the fiscal imperatives tie our hands. Rubin was a big supporter of pay-as-you-go-budget rules, now adopted by the Democratic congressional majority. These rules limit further Republican tax cutting, but they also hobble Democrats' ability to spend more than token sums on new initiatives.

3/1/06

Low-income resident s left out in the cold

This was originally published at Spare Change News. (Sorry no online version is available at the SCN web site at this time)

Last fall, Massachusetts legislators on both federal and state levels, concerned about how high energy prices, advocated for increased heating bill assistance, urging Congress to allot $5.1 billion for the Low Income Home Energy Assistance Program (LIHEAP). But at years end – in the final moments of the 2005 Senate session – legislators slashed the amount considerably, to $2.16 billion.

That figure, according to energy assistance officials, is far less than the 4.5 billion that is needed to keep poor families warm, and the more than 14,000 thousand Boston resident eligible for aid, according to local organizations, will be left, quite literally, out in the cold.

“It’s devastating,” said Kathy Tobin, the energy programs director for ABCD. “To households in the Boston area with vital needs, this is catastrophic.”

According to Action for Boston Community Development (ABCD) the poorest families can receive a maximum of $765 for energy expenses, or enough for about one tank of heating oil. The average household uses three to four tanks during the winter months. Advocates of LIHEAP, insist that this level of assistance has been stagnant for over a decade. “If you adjust for inflation, the purchasing power of LIHEAP funding is only a little over half of what it was in 1982,” said Massachusetts Senator Ted Kennedy on a report on his Web site.

In fact, despite the rise of energy costs, the 2005 federal budget actually allotted more money than did the budget for 2006. Yet, the average heating bill has gone up considerably, 48 percent for those who rely on natural gas and 32 percent for those who use oil.

Larry Chretien, director of Massachusetts Energy Consumers Alliance, reached by phone, said that the federal assistance provided today provides residents only about one third of the heating oil, than it did about 15 years ago. “If you do the math, heating assistance has not only not kept up with the pace of inflation, as well as the rising cot of energy,’’Chretien.said.

While options are few for needy households, and oil the country’s largest oil companies – who are recording record profits – Boston residents have received some help from the state legislature, which having allocated $20 million in emergency heating aid, the largest figure ever in the history of the state, said Tobin.

In the months leading up to the winter, Senate President Robert E. Travaglini along with House speaker Salvatore Dimasi introduced new legislation to combat the soaring energy costs. Home Energy Assistance & Tax Relief (H.E.A.T.), a program of tax credits and various incentives designed to help Massachusetts energy consumers deal with their heating bills. “This bill provides immediate relief from high heating bills and encourages consumers to cash-in on long term savings with incentives for buying products to make their homes more energy efficient,” said Travaglini in a Nov. 18, press release.

The bill was signed into law by Gov. Mitt Romney in November.

Travaglini’s communications director, Ann Dufresne, said that the Senate President has been very committed in coming up with legislation that would help the lower and middle class families deal with their rising heating bills. “Those are the people who are truly suffering,” she said.

“The State really stepped up on this issue, in the early winter,” said Tobin. Massachusetts Senators, Kennedy and John Kerry have also among those who advocated increased aid for needy families.

Help has also come in the form of charitable organizations, such as The United Way, and foreign governments, including the Venezuelan government who announced that it would provide 12 million gallons of heating oil at a discounted rate to families in New England "We want to help the poorest communities in the US," said Venezuelan President, Hugo Chávez, who was quoted in The Christian Science Monitor in November. "There are people who die from the cold in winter in the US," he added.

The deal, which was brokered by State Rep. Bill Delahunt and former representative Joe Kennedy, has been criticized by some, who oppose Chavez. “"Leave it to the congressman ... and a Kennedy to close the deal," read a Nov. 30 Wall Street Journal Editorial.

But Chretien said he thinks Boston residents will buy the discounted oil. “When people’s assistance runs out, I think they will take advantage.”

The discounted Venezuelan oil, while helpful, is still unattainable for some poor families, since in order to get the discount, they will need to come up with cash, which is not always easy to do, Tobin said. “They just don’t have the money.”

“Families have to make some tough choices,” Tobin added. “In some cases they have to decide whether to buy food or to turn the thermostat on.”

Another problem, according to Chretien, is that residents have been using dangerous methods to heat their house, such as using their stove, or dangerous space heaters. “Were finding that when prices are high, there are fires, people are not eating, or taking their drugs … even homelessness, he said.

So far the winter has been relatively mild in Boston – which has been a break for many residents. “Were damn lucky,” said Chretien, who is quick to remind everyone that it is a “long winter,” and just one or two bad cold fronts could drive cost to a breaking point.

Most of us can manage the rising energy costs,” said Chretein. “But for some, it’s the straw that breaks the camels back.”